I love the look of these cards, the colors and graphics are excellent! The real downside and reason why I'm only giving them 3 stars is that the edges of the cards quickly get scuffed as I broke them in. Because the majority of the card is black, the scuffs show up very quickly and can look like distinctive marks. Maybe it is because I am new to magic and have been rough on them that the edges have gotten scuffed. Either way, that has been the only drawback for me.